Why Attribution Gets Messy (And Why No Platform Plays Nice)

Digital platforms are all about their own interests—Meta, Google, TikTok, you name it. They each want credit for driving sales, meaning brands get wildly inflated metrics and often miss the bigger picture.

Consider this: Let’s say a customer clicks on a Meta ad, sees a Google ad, and later completes the purchase. Meta wants to say, “That was all me,” while Google chimes in, “Actually, I closed the deal.” Now you’re left with two credited conversions for one sale—ROAS looks great, but does it really tell you who drove the most impact?

‍

Meta vs. Google (Last Click, View-Through… Who’s Counting?)

Let’s break down why platforms don’t see eye-to-eye:

Google Ads: Works off a last-click model, giving credit to the final ad before the purchase. Meta Ads: Mixes it up with view-through attribution, counting anyone who even saw the ad as influenced. Pro Tip: When in doubt, look for metrics that better align with your brand’s goals than the platform’s pre-defined metrics.

‍

ROAS: The Metric That Might Be Lying to You

ROAS (Return on Ad Spend) has been around forever, but it’s not always what it seems. Sure, it’s tempting to treat ROAS like a golden standard—it’s easy, it’s familiar. But when you’re trying to scale or genuinely understand performance, ROAS alone can be, well… misleading.

Here’s why it’s tricky:

• Overlapping Credit: A single customer journey might involve multiple platforms. If both Meta and Google claim conversion credit, your ROAS shoots up on paper but doesn’t reflect the actual impact.

• Short-Term Focus: ROAS loves a quick win. But are these platforms actually contributing to long-term growth, or just showing short-term wins to boost their own metrics?

‍

Think Beyond ROAS:
Instead of obsessing over ROAS, ask yourself:

    ⦿    How much of my traffic is genuinely new?

    ⦿    Are these customers coming back for more?

‍

When (and If) Attribution Tools Make Sense

There are countless attribution tools out there—Triple Whale, HiRoS, Ruler Analytics, the list goes on. They each offer to clean up your tracking confusion, but the price tags can be steep, and not every brand needs them.

If you’re spending upwards of $50k+ per month on ads and operating across multiple channels (not just Google and Meta, but influencers, email, maybe even TV), then yeah, a comprehensive attribution tool might bring value. For most brands, though? You’re better off investing in your basics.

‍

Consider These Tips:

• GA4: Google Analytics 4 offers surprisingly strong cross-channel tracking and is a must-have for anyone running even modest ad budgets.‍
• Server-Side Tracking: Get better data capture by avoiding cookie limitations. Tools like Tealium or sGTM (Server-side Google Tag Manager) can fill the gaps, especially as privacy rules tighten.

‍

Back to Basics: The Fundamentals Matter More Than Ever

Let’s be real: Before diving into costly software, get the essentials right. This means configuring GA4, creating UTM tagging standards, and establishing clear event tracking. It’s amazing how far these basics will get you.

‍

What are the fundamentals?

• UTM Tagging: Set up a consistent UTM tagging framework across all channels. This alone can offer insights into where traffic is really coming from.‍
• Event Tracking: Make sure that actions like “Add to Cart,” “Purchase,” or even “Video Watch” are being tracked effectively in GA4 or your CRM.‍
• Server-Side Tracking: Invest in server-side tracking if you’re dealing with ad blockers or browser restrictions. This ensures that even as cookies disappear, you’re still capturing valuable user data.

‍

Quick Wins:
By focusing on these core elements, you’ll get a much clearer view of performance, often without needing pricey software.

‍

Moving Beyond ROAS for a Fuller Picture

Alright, so we’ve covered ROAS and the basics. But to really get where customers are coming from, it’s time to think in terms of “Total Impact”—the full journey customers take to reach your brand. This isn’t just a “last-click” mindset; it’s about understanding every step.

‍

Why Total Impact?

Customers don’t usually buy on a whim. They might see an influencer mention, click on a Meta ad, get retargeted by Google, and then finally buy. So, to get the full story, brands need multi-touch attribution, which captures the entire journey.

Here’s what that could look like:

• Multi-Touch Journey Mapping: Imagine a customer sees four different touchpoints before purchasing. Multi-touch attribution ensures credit isn’t solely given to the last click.‍
• Use Post-Purchase Surveys: To get even deeper insights, use post-purchase surveys and ask where customers first heard about you. Sometimes the best data isn’t the one you track with pixels but the answer you get straight from the source.

Takeaway: Instead of focusing purely on last-click metrics, broaden your view to understand which channels spark interest and which close the sale.

‍

Conclusion
Tracking will probably never be perfect, but that doesn’t mean you can’t find clarity. By combining foundational tracking with a broader view of attribution, brands can actually start to make data-driven decisions that drive growth, not just numbers on a report. It’s about looking at your brand’s full journey and investing in metrics that actually matter.